Why Does Starting Over Feel So Hard?

When you picture yourself at your most comfortable, you probably see yourself in your bedroom, maybe walking down a familiar street, or perhaps sitting and eating your favourite meal at your favourite restaurant. Those places hold wonderful memories for you, but they also offer you the warm hug of familiarity.
We tend to feel safer when we know what to expect. We know the route home, where things are kept, who we can call, what our day usually looks like, and where we fit into the world around us.
Starting over can shake all of that. Uprooting our expectations for conduct, routines, and even safe spaces. Change is a constant in our lives but even tiny changes can have ripple effects on our mood and confidence. I don’t even like when my football team slightly changes their uniforms. So I absolutely experience anxiety and trepidation when starting school, a new job, or moving altogether.
Major life changes can be exciting, but can also leave you feeling strangely unsettled. Suddenly, the routines, relationships, and places that helped life feel predictable and safe are different, and you may find yourself having to rebuild that sense of comfort from the ground up.
That does not mean the transition is going badly. Sometimes, you are adjusting to a life that has not become familiar yet.
Why Change Can Feel Uncomfortable
The brain has a remarkable ability to adjust to its circumstances. You may hate a new job, school, or house at first glance. You might remark that it's worse than the old one. You might even be right. And yet, after some time, those tremendous negative feelings may begin to subside.
You may even find yourself appreciating the change, perhaps celebrating having made it. This isn't necessarily a miracle or a sudden change of mind. It's partly the result of your brain gradually becoming familiar with something new.
Our brains are constantly trying to make sense of the world around us. We know which situations are comfortable and which people we can rely on, when we are transferred to a new environment that grasp of predictability disappears.
Our brains may respond to uncertainty with increased feelings of alertness, anxiety, or discomfort. This is especially true when we feel that something important is at stake, like making new friends, succeeding academically, or finding our place in a new community. Think about your first day at a new school compared to your hundredth. The building hasn't necessarily changed, but your experience of it probably has. You know where your classes are, you've developed relationships, and you've had opportunities to learn what to expect.
What once required a tremendous amount of thought and energy can eventually become second nature. The important thing to recognize is that feeling uncomfortable in a new environment doesn't automatically mean it's a bad environment.
We Don't Always Realize What We're Leaving Behind
One of the more difficult parts of starting over is that we often focus on the big changes without recognizing the importance of the smaller things we're leaving behind.
For example, someone moving away to university might be excited about their newfound independence but surprised by how much they miss eating dinner with their family, or sleeping in their childhood bedroom. Someone starting a new job might miss their old coworkers, knowing exactly what was expected of them, or the confidence that came from years of experience.
These might seem like small things, but together they contribute to our sense of stability, comfort, and belonging. Sometimes, starting over can even involve a sense of grief.
We tend to associate grief with death or significant loss, but we can also grieve the routines, relationships, and experiences that were important to us during earlier chapters of our lives.You can be genuinely excited about a new opportunity and still feel sad about what you've left behind. Those feelings don't cancel each other out.
The Pressure to Adjust Quickly
Another challenge of starting over is the expectation that we should immediately feel happy, confident, or comfortable with our decisions. If you spent months looking forward to moving out, beginning university, or accepting a new position, you may expect to be completely immersed in that new experience. However, when the experience finally arrives, you may wonder why you're feeling anxious or lonely instead of excited.
You may begin questioning whether you've made the right decision. It's worth remembering that our expectations about a transition and our actual emotional experience don't always line up. Adjusting takes time, and there isn't one correct way to experience a major life change.
We also have a tendency to compare our new circumstances with the ones we've left behind. Unfortunately, these comparisons aren't always fair. You may be comparing your first month in a new environment with several years spent building relationships, confidence, and familiarity somewhere else.
Try to remember that those previous experiences weren't always familiar, either. There was probably a time when the people, places, and routines you miss today were once completely new to you.
What Can Help When You're Starting Over?
Although we can't always eliminate the discomfort that comes with change, there are ways to make the adjustment process a little easier.
1. Keep some familiar routines.
Starting over doesn't mean you need to change everything about your life. Maintaining familiar habits, hobbies, or relationships can provide a sense of stability during uncertain times.
2. Give yourself opportunities to become comfortable.
Familiarity develops through experience. Exploring your new neighbourhood, participating in activities, or gradually developing relationships can help an unfamiliar environment begin to feel like your own.
3. Be mindful of your expectations.
It's okay if your new experience doesn't immediately live up to what you imagined. Try not to interpret every uncomfortable moment as evidence that you've made the wrong decision.
4. Allow yourself to miss the past.
You don't have to pretend that everything about your previous circumstances was worse. There may be things you genuinely loved and still wish you had. Recognizing those feelings can be an important part of moving forward.
5. Give yourself time.
Perhaps most importantly, remember that adjustment isn't something we can always rush. Some people settle into new circumstances relatively quickly, while others need more time and support.
What Can Therapy Do To Help?
If you’ve never been to therapy before, you may think therapists position themselves as having all the answers, but that's not true. The work benefits significantly from collaboration on goal-setting. Identifying what matters most to you, and figuring out in tandem what moving forward might actually look like.
For someone navigating a major life transition, that work might look like exploring the anxiety that comes with uncertainty, building confidence in unfamiliar social situations, or finding ways to maintain meaningful connections while establishing new ones. It might also involve exploring your identity, especially when a new environment challenges the roles, routines, or expectations you've grown accustomed to.
Therapy can provide an opportunity to better understand what makes these changes difficult while also recognizing the opportunities for growth that come with them.
I also believe it's important to recognize that not everything uncomfortable absolutely needs to be fixed immediately or at all. Missing your friends, nervous feelings about a new school, questioning a big decision are all understandable human experiences. Rather than trying to eliminate those feelings, I like to work in tandem to understand them, develop ways to manage them, and make sure they aren't preventing you from pursuing the things that matter to you.
My approach to therapy is grounded in the belief that you are the expert on your own experiences. My role is not to tell you what decisions to make, but to offer a space where we can explore your thoughts and feelings together, challenge unhelpful patterns, recognize your existing strengths, and build new skills where they might be helpful.
Starting over can be overwhelming, but you don't have to have everything figured out before asking for support. Sometimes therapy is simply a place to make sense of where you've been, where you are, and where you hope to go next.
Michael Pincente in an MSW Candidate from the University of Toronto, completing his Clinical Practicum at Milton Psychotherapy Centre. While he is fulfilling his practicum requirements, his work is being supervised by Kanica Coshal, MSW, RSW. To book your first appointments with Michael, you can use our online booking portal, call (905) 878-3543 or email our Admin Team at info@miltontherapycentre.com




Comments